Friday, August 26, 2011

today they are women




We're heading to the city in a little while. My twin grandgirls are having their Bat Mitzvah this weekend. The Bat Mitzvah is a coming of age ceremony in Judaism that up until modern times was exclusively for boys. Only boys and men are commanded in the Torah to study the Torah (the religious writings also known as the 'old testament') and the other religious books, the Haftorah, the Mishna and the Talmud.

I would go to Torah study while my kids were in religious school to avoid all the driving back and forth and also because I was very interested in the origins of religions back then. One day I asked the Rabbi why only the men were commanded by god to study the commands of god. He told me because women were closer to god and would do what was right by nature. Only the men had to be taught what was right. Maybe that's why they felt the need to subjugate us. I also asked him how Lot could be considered a righteous man when he offered his virgin daughters to strangers for sex, but he just sort of brushed off that one saying times were different then. But we're still supposed to follow all those ancient rules.

Anyway, back to the subject at hand.

The Bat Mitzvah (Bar Mitzvah for boys) is as I said, a coming of age ceremony. The celebrant leads the Shabbat service, reads from the torah, gives a little sermon and is considered an adult in the eyes of god and the community. Bad behavior is no longer excused because you are too young to know better and you are responsible for your actions and the consequences of those actions.

One of the things I liked about Judaism is that any adult can conduct services. There is no requirement to have an ordained religious leader. They, do, of course, have those, but Rabbis are considered teachers, the most learned among them and not the spokesman of god.

But Judaism is, in the end, still a religion and I just don't do religion. I chose to raise my kids in the Jewish tradition, their father is Jewish, because even though I don't care for religion, I thought they should have some kind of foundation, mostly to protect them from the allure of cults. Cults were big when I was a young adult and I saw lots of rootless kids get sucked up by them. I fully expected them, as adults, to question and even forego religion altogether as I did.

So now I am about to see my grandgirls Bat Mitzvah. They will start the day as children and end it as adults. This is not an easy thing to do. They have been going to extra classes twice a week for three years to prepare for this day.

We are very proud of them.


22 comments:

  1. How interesting that your kids adhered to their religion even though you as a parent were unattached to its structure and some of the ideas. Still, you are a spiritual person, and a thinker, the most important part of religion.

    Congratulation on the twins' Bat Mitzvah; it is a real accomplishment.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Religion is a difficult thing...you give the basics, then they will have to make their own decision ...Unfortunately too many adults never think for themselves and just go along for the ride...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Enjoy your evening Ellen - I live in a predominantly Orthodox Jewish area over here but I hadn't heard of Bat Mitvah before, only the one for the boys.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Of course your would be proud of them.

    I find your rational for basing your kids faith in Judiasm [or any mainstream religion] to avoid cults very interesting, [something I have never heard of actually] although you don't believe in religion, per se.

    I guess it worked?

    ReplyDelete
  5. PS - yes, I have heard of cults - never heard of your method for avoiding is what I meant. Sorry I wasn't clear.

    ReplyDelete
  6. in my own experience, religion is a good place to begin the process of questioning . . . . steven

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hope you have a cool party- Rites of passage are sorely missing in our non culture- I think that inventing your own is preferable to religious ones and I am sure you have made that clear to the kids. Be glad!

    ReplyDelete
  8. When they pass into adult life it is also up to them to continue study if they like.I let my children choose what they wanted, but still discussed different ideologies.

    ReplyDelete
  9. oh, congrats to your granddaughters!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I hope you have a lovely weekend, and I hope the ceremony is a great blessing for the whole family!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I find religion endlessly fascinating, not as an adherent of any particular one but as an observer of the customs and traditions.

    I think customs and traditions are very important, as are the teachings of all of them (has there ever been a religion which teaches to do wrong?). 'Belonging' is important to anchor so many of us.

    Congratulations to the whole family; may the girls flourish and may their lives be fruitful and happy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I guess your granddaughters will choose for themselves in the future. As for now, they are learning that rules are supposed to help you live a good life.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm fascinated by the Rabbi's answer to you about women. On the surface it seems really nice - but I'm left feeling kind of like it was condescending. On the other hand, I like it better than the traditional protestant take on women :)

    Hope you had a great time & that the girls enjoyed their day.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Oh Ellen~ how proud indeed you must be!
    I too found your Rabbi's answer very interesting.
    In my Catholic practice, we call our coming of age, Confirmation. It is when children (usually around the age of 14,15)after a year of deeper study of our Faith, make their religious decision, of being confirmed as a Catholic. Their parents are no longer responsible, rather they are now, for their religious choice.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Raised Methodist, I had urges toward Catholicism during my college years, but couldn't abide the patriarchal structure or their attitude toward women. I ended as a Luther-an, hyphenated because Luther himself had a way of understanding the world that appealed to me. None of this either/or business. He was all both/and.

    In any event, your girls may take their own circuitous paths, but now those paths are truly before them, open and exciting. Congratulations to all of you for what they've accomplished, and best wishes for a happy and secure future.

    ReplyDelete
  16. "times were different then"

    What an answer! It was okay then for righteous men to allow their daughters to be raped and murdered, so what's your problem with it! I'm practically rolling with laughter.

    I don't know if you can protect your kids from cults by giving them a minimal exposure to religion anymore than if you raised them as atheists. I can sure understand why you would want to try though.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm with you and Snowbrush -- the "different times" argument just boggles the mind. But it is an accomplishment to learn to read the Torah in Hebrew and to choose a passage to read and give a sermon about, so kudos to your grand-girls.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I am not religious either, but I have always been fascinated with Judaism. There are so many situations, like that of Lot, that I question in religion.

    Congrats to the girls, though! They have accomplished what they set out to do and that's a great quality :)!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Please don't be cross, but I have nominated you for a meme. The details are here, I really hope you give it a whirl.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Ellen I had never heard of this for girls so I have to say even though I am not Jewish, this makes me very excited. I always wondered why it was just for boys. Congratulations to the girls, it will be a very important day for them. hope you are well. take care.

    ReplyDelete
  21. It is a wonderful tradition to celebrate. I, too, have asked questions, where I recieved no answers. I have to say I love the answer to the first question..."women were closer to God and would do what was right by nature"

    ReplyDelete
  22. You must be very proud of them, Ellen. Mazel Tov to the twins and their supportive family.

    ReplyDelete

I opened my big mouth, now it's your turn.